Don't fade into a trend
Fades on NQ taken while the QuantLogic NQ indicator showed a trend against the trade lost far more than fades taken while it was grey, the undecided state, often 2 to 5 times more. It held on 2017 to 2023 and again on three later years. Most grey fades still lost after costs: the rule is the skip, not a reason to fade.
The question
Many traders fade: they sell a stretch up and buy a stretch down, expecting price to come back. It works on range days and hurts on trend days. Can a trader tell the two apart at the moment of entry?
The QuantLogic NQ indicator turns green or red when several of our tested data points agree on a side, and stays grey when they don't. We asked whether fades do better when it is grey.
What we ran
- NQ 1-minute bars, November 2017 to November 2026. The settings were fixed on November 2017 to October 2023 and read once on November 2023 to November 2026.
- RSI fade: buy when the 14-bar RSI crosses under 30, sell short when it crosses over 70, on 1-minute and 5-minute bars. Stop and target a quarter of the usual day range, out after 60 minutes at most.
- VWAP fade: sell a stretch above VWAP or buy a stretch below it, target VWAP, stop a quarter of the usual day range.
- Each trade is labelled by the indicator at the entry minute: grey, or coloured against the trade. 1 micro contract, $2.52 round trip of costs.
Results
| Fade | Grey, 2017–2023 | Against the trend, 2017–2023 | Grey, 2023–2026 | Against the trend, 2023–2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| RSI 5-min, long | +3.1 | −9.8 | −4.9 | −17.6 |
| RSI 5-min, short | +0.8 | −15.0 | +6.0 | −15.3 |
| RSI 1-min, long | −2.0 | −0.2 | −6.5 | −18.1 |
| RSI 1-min, short | −4.0 | −13.0 | −4.6 | −22.4 |
| VWAP fade, all | −4.2 | −15.8 | −4.7 | −11.0 |
Grey lost less in 9 of the 10 comparisons, and in all five on the later years.
The open matters too. When the indicator showed any colour in the first 10 minutes, shorting a stretch above VWAP in the next two hours lost about $46 to $54 a trade on 2023 to 2026. On grey opens the same short made about $9 to $10.
A day that was grey all morning did not make afternoon fades better. What counts is the reading at the moment you enter.
Why it might be so
A fade bets that nobody is pushing the market hard. When several independent measures agree that buyers or sellers are in control, that bet is wrong more often, and the move against you is bigger.
Grey does not mean the market will snap back. It only means no side is clearly in control, so the fade loses its worst enemy.
What it means when you test
If you fade, use colour as a reason to stand aside: don't fade into a trend.
Don't read grey as a signal to fade. Most grey fades still lost after costs.
On a coloured open, wait. The worst fades of all came on days that opened with a clear trend.
Limits
One market, two fade setups and a few settings each, which leaves some room for luck. The indicator's data points are our own research and are not listed here. Past results, not a promise, and nothing here is a trading signal.
Simulated results on past market data. Research only, not trading signals or advice. Past results do not promise future ones; see the hypothetical performance disclosure at the bottom of the page.
Get this note as a PDF
Leave your email and the PDF downloads straight away. Easy to keep, print or pass on.
Test your own ideas the same way
Analyze runs any idea on NQ, ES, gold, oil and Bitcoin with costs, both halves and a luck check, so you can see whether it beats chance before you trade it.
Past results on market data, not a forecast. No advice and no signals.
More research
We test the ideas traders talk about
Popular trading ideas tested after costs and against luck, including the ones that failed.
How to read the QuantLogic NQ indicator
What the green, red and gray strip under the NQ chart means, how it held on three unseen years, and what it does not do.
What AI can and can't find in trading
AI finds patterns, including ones that aren't there. Used honestly, it kills bad ideas before they cost you money, and it can still find small edges that last.
Skip the worst trades, don't pick the best ones
Leaving out the worst value of a data point carried a third less luck than keeping only the best, and kept 92% of the trades. More history shrank luck more than any rule.
Educational content, not investment advice. Futures trading involves substantial risk of loss. See the risk disclosure.